Ebenezer (2026) ❄️📜

Ebenezer (2026) ❄️📜 Review – Bah Humbug! Someone Forgot the Christmas Spirit!

A Christmas Carol Meets a Horror Movie, but Where’s the Christmas Cheer?

Let’s Start by Showing Y’all the Trailers, Shall We?

⚠️ Content Warning

Before watching Ebenezer (2026), I think it’s important to emphasize that this is a considerably darker and more disturbing adaptation of A Christmas Carol than audiences might expect.

Parent’s, do not take your kids to see this movie, they will be scared. This ain’t no cheerful jolly story.

Despite being based on a beloved Christmas story, this movie leans heavily into gothic horror, featuring frightening ghostly appearances, disturbing body horror, skeletal and corpse-like imagery, death, graveyards, and unsettling supernatural sequences that could genuinely frighten younger viewers.

The film also contains some incredibly bleak subject matter, including extreme poverty, homelessness, hunger, child illness, the death of a child in a possible future, grief, and the harsh treatment of vulnerable people.

And I really want to emphasize that this is not a particularly cheerful Christmas movie. Although it ultimately delivers a message about kindness and redemption, much of the film is relentlessly gloomy, depressing, and emotionally uncomfortable.

If you’re looking for a lighthearted, festive adaptation to watch with the kids on Christmas Eve, I would strongly recommend considering another version.

This is very much a horror-oriented interpretation of Dickens’s story, and I wouldn’t recommend it for young or particularly sensitive viewers.

Just because it’s A Christmas Carol doesn’t automatically mean it’s family-friendly. Trust me, some of these ghosts look like they wandered onto the wrong movie set!

Also how many adaptations of a Christmas Carol do we need? Whats this one the umpteenth adaptation?

Non-Spoiler Plot Overview

At this point, do I really need to explain the plot of A Christmas Carol? We’ve had countless adaptations of Charles Dickens’s famous novella, and I’m pretty sure everyone and their grandmother knows how this story plays out. Ebenezer Scrooge is a miserable old man who hates Christmas, gets visited by three spirits, witnesses his past, present, and possible future, and eventually learns to become a better person. There, that’s the story!

And for the most part, Ebenezer follows those familiar story beats pretty faithfully. However, what makes this particular adaptation interesting isn’t necessarily the story itself, but how director Ti West approaches it.

West, who is known for horror movies such as X, Pearl, and MaXXXine, decides to embrace the gothic horror elements of Dickens’s novella. And considering that A Christmas Carol is technically a ghost story, I was actually pretty excited about this approach.

Now, before anyone thinks I’m against making A Christmas Carol scary, let me remind y’all that my favorite adaptation is Disney’s 2009 animated film starring Jim Carrey. That movie is practically a horror movie in disguise, and I absolutely love it.

So naturally, a darker, more horror-oriented adaptation sounded right up my alley.

And you know what? For the most part, I enjoyed it!

But I also have some rather significant problems with this movie, particularly when it comes to its understanding of what makes A Christmas Carol such a wonderful Christmas story.

Because yes, Ti West, we understand that Dickens wrote a ghost story. But underneath all the ghosts, death, and misery, there’s also a story about hope, kindness, redemption, and the joy of Christmas.

And unfortunately, I think this movie sometimes forgets that.

Character Rundown

Johnny Depp as Ebenezer Scrooge

Let’s start with Johnny Depp, who I thought gave a pretty good performance as Scrooge. He handles the character’s bitterness, guilt, sadness, and eventual redemption rather well, particularly during the more emotional scenes.

However, I have to talk about his appearance because, good lord, what were they thinking?

I don’t know whether it’s the makeup, prosthetics, hairstyle, or a combination of everything, but something about Depp’s Scrooge just looks off to me. His head looks unusually large, and rather than seeing a believable elderly Ebenezer Scrooge, I sometimes felt like I was just looking at Johnny Depp wearing gray hair and excessive makeup.

I’m not saying he needed to look exactly like Jim Carrey’s version or Patrick Stewart’s interpretation. But I do think the character’s appearance could have been handled better.

Thankfully, Depp’s performance is considerably stronger than the makeup surrounding it.

Ian McKellen as Jacob Marley

Ian McKellen is an excellent actor, which makes my disappointment with his scene particularly frustrating.

Marley’s appearance is one of the most iconic moments in A Christmas Carol, and while I appreciate the horror imagery, I really didn’t care for how the conversation between Marley and Scrooge was written.

The dialogue feels incredibly rushed and unnatural, almost as though the actors are simply reciting famous lines from the novella rather than having an actual conversation.

And that’s disappointing because this scene should be frightening, emotional, and incredibly important to Scrooge’s journey.

McKellen certainly isn’t the problem here. I think the writing lets him down.

Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit

I really enjoyed Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit.

Bob is supposed to be a hardworking, kindhearted family man who deserves considerably better treatment than what Scrooge gives him, and Grint does a good job portraying that.

The scenes involving Bob and Tiny Tim are particularly touching, and I appreciate that the movie gives Bob some genuinely emotional moments without losing his fundamental kindness.

Sam Claflin as Fred

Fred is another character I thought was handled rather well, particularly when it comes to his relationship with Scrooge.

The movie expands on why Fred continues trying to include his uncle in Christmas celebrations despite being repeatedly rejected, and I thought that was one of its strongest additions.

There’s a real sense of sadness underneath Fred’s optimism, and Claflin does a good job portraying that.

Ellie Bamber as Belle and Arthur Conti as Young Scrooge

I really appreciated the additional attention given to Scrooge’s younger years and his relationship with Belle.

Their relationship is already an important part of Dickens’s story, but this adaptation introduces some additional emotional details that I thought worked beautifully.

These scenes help us understand just how much Scrooge sacrificed in his pursuit of wealth, and they’re among the more effective emotional moments in the movie.

Andrea Riseborough as the Ghost of Christmas Past

GOOD LORD, WHAT HAPPENED TO CHRISTMAS PAST?!

Instead of the more gentle, mysterious spirit we’re accustomed to seeing, this version looks like something Guillermo del Toro might have designed after having a particularly unpleasant nightmare.

She’s pale, emaciated, has creepy white eyes, and looks like she hasn’t eaten anything in approximately three centuries.

I actually like the frightening design from a horror perspective, but I also question whether it was appropriate for this particular spirit.

And hilariously, I think she’s actually scarier than the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come!

Tramell Tillman as the Ghost of Christmas Present

Now, this is where I have some mixed feelings.

Traditionally, the Ghost of Christmas Present is cheerful, larger than life, and practically overflowing with Christmas spirit. He’s surrounded by food, laughter, and celebration, but he also knows when to become serious.

This version? Not so much. I mean look at them.

Ghost of Christmas Past
Ghost Of Christmas Present
Ghost Of Christmas Yet To Come

Lets talk about Ghost Of Present for a second,

He’s intimidating, impatient, and practically hostile toward Scrooge from the moment they meet.

I appreciate Tillman’s commanding performance, but I really miss the warmth and humor that traditionally make this spirit so memorable.

Robert Strange as the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come

I actually thought this spirit looked pretty creepy, with its black hood, crow-like appearance, and grim-reaper imagery.

However, I also found the design somewhat underwhelming compared with the previous two spirits.

Considering that Christmas Yet to Come is supposed to be the most frightening of the three, that’s a little disappointing.

Personally, I still prefer the living-shadow interpretation from Disney’s 2009 adaptation.

Daisy Ridley as Fred’s Wife

And finally, we have Daisy Ridley as Fred’s wife.

Yep, Daisy Ridley is in this movie!

Something I found rather annoying was that IMDb and several other platforms didn’t seem to identify who she was playing beforehand.

But after actually watching the movie, I can somewhat understand why.

She has approximately two lines!

Seriously, she’s barely a character. It’s a rather small role for such a recognizable actress.

Pacing / Episode Flow

For the most part, I thought the movie moved along reasonably well.

It follows the familiar structure of Dickens’s novella, with Scrooge encountering Marley before being visited by the three Christmas spirits.

However, the movie also introduces some new sequences and expands several familiar moments, which I appreciated.

I particularly enjoyed the fact that Scrooge doesn’t simply accept everything happening to him. At times, he actively tries to escape the supernatural events unfolding around him.

That makes his journey feel a little more unpredictable, even when we already know how the story ends.

However, some scenes feel rushed, particularly the encounter with Marley, while others seem more interested in creating disturbing imagery than developing the story.

And that brings me to one of my biggest problems with this movie.

It’s incredibly bleak.

Now, I understand that Victorian London wasn’t exactly a wonderful place to live, particularly if you were poor.

But good lord, does this movie ever want to remind you of that!

Everything looks dirty, miserable, gloomy, and unpleasant. Even the Christmas celebrations don’t provide much relief from the depressing atmosphere.

And after a while, that becomes exhausting.

There’s nothing inherently wrong with a dark adaptation of A Christmas Carol, but the story needs a balance between its frightening supernatural elements and its joyful Christmas message.

Unfortunately, I don’t think Ti West consistently finds that balance.

Pros

One of the things I appreciated most about Ebenezer was its willingness to embrace the horror elements of Dickens’s original story.

The ghosts are genuinely unsettling, the atmosphere is appropriately gothic, and several sequences feel like they belong in a full-blown horror movie.

As someone who loves the frightening elements of the 2009 adaptation, I certainly appreciated that.

I also enjoyed the production design, even though I have some problems with how relentlessly unpleasant everything looks.

The movie certainly succeeds in creating a grim, dirty, and oppressive version of Victorian London.

And while I don’t necessarily agree with every creative decision, I appreciate that the filmmakers tried to give this adaptation its own identity.

I particularly enjoyed several of the additions involving Scrooge’s relationships with Belle, Fred, and Bob Cratchit.

These moments add emotional weight to familiar characters without completely abandoning Dickens’s original story.

Johnny Depp also deserves credit for his performance. Despite my problems with his appearance, I thought he handled Scrooge’s emotional journey rather well.

And finally, I appreciate that the movie remains largely faithful to the core story.

For all its horror imagery and original additions, this is still recognizably A Christmas Carol.

It doesn’t completely reinvent Dickens’s story simply for the sake of being different.

Cons

Now, unfortunately, I have quite a few problems with this movie.

And my biggest criticism is something that became increasingly apparent the more I thought about it.

Where the hell is the Christmas spirit?!

Seriously!

For a movie based on one of the most beloved Christmas stories ever written, there’s surprisingly little Christmas joy.

I understand wanting to make the ghosts frightening, but did practically every aspect of the movie need to be so miserable?

The Ghost of Christmas Past looks like a corpse that was dragged out the lake, the Ghost of Christmas looks like candymans pimp uncle, and Victorian London looks like a place where happiness goes to die.

Its completely backwards that the first 2 ghosts look more terrifying than the 3rd ghost.

So when the ghost of Christmas Yet to Come appears? Its almost like you get this feeling of oh ok, not like you can make this night any scarier.

Even when the movie shows moments of kindness, there’s very little genuine celebration.

And I think that’s a major problem.

Also, another issue. I just realized this movie portrays poor people as the bad guys, and they made the fundraiser charity men be Laundering schemers. Wow, this is not a surprise coming from skydance and its CEO.

I’m not gonna get political. I’m just gonna leave it there. If you know, you know, if not, I would say look it up, but honestly I don’t care if you do or don’t, but yeah, the more I think about it, this movie is just so anti. Lower class citizen and more pro higher class citizenship. Wow because this is what Dickens was aiming for when he wrote the book.


The reason I love Disney’s 2009 adaptation so much is because it understands how to balance horror with Christmas joy.

It can frighten you one moment and make you smile the next.

You get the creepy ghosts, the frightening supernatural imagery, and the darker elements of Dickens’s story, but you also get laughter, warmth, colorful Christmas celebrations, and a genuinely uplifting ending.

Ebenezer seems so determined to emphasize the horror that it occasionally forgets the happiness underneath.

And then there’s the movie’s treatment of poverty.

Now, before anyone misunderstands me, I’m not suggesting that Dickens’s story should ignore poverty.

Quite the opposite.

Poverty is one of the most important themes of A Christmas Carol.

But I think there’s a difference between effectively exploring a social issue and constantly reminding the audience how miserable everything is.

Dickens gives us Bob Cratchit and his family, allowing us to become emotionally invested in their struggles.

We care about Bob. We care about Tiny Tim. We want to see their circumstances improve.

And through these characters, we understand the larger problems affecting Victorian society.

The novella also acknowledges suffering beyond the Cratchit household, but it doesn’t allow that suffering to overwhelm every aspect of the story.

This movie, however, seems determined to show poverty practically everywhere.

We see homeless people, shelters, and countless reminders of how awful life is for the lower classes.

And eventually, I started wondering what exactly the movie wanted me to feel hopeful about.

Because even when Scrooge becomes a better person, what happens to everybody else?

Bob and his family might receive a happier ending, but what about the countless other people suffering throughout London?

Are they simply supposed to continue being miserable because they weren’t fortunate enough to know Ebenezer Scrooge?

Merry Christmas, everybody!

And I think this is where the film’s emphasis on poverty starts working against its own message.

The original story uses personal relationships to explore larger social problems.

This adaptation expands the suffering so much that Scrooge’s redemption sometimes feels insufficient.

And that’s frustrating because the movie has some genuinely wonderful moments of compassion.

I just wish it had remembered to include more happiness alongside them.

Another problem is the inconsistency of its creative decisions.

For every handful of excellent ideas the movie introduces, there seem to be just as many questionable ones.

Some additions genuinely improve the story, while others feel unnecessary or poorly executed.

And while I enjoyed the horror-oriented approach, I think the movie occasionally mistakes being relentlessly miserable for being appropriately frightening.

There’s a difference.

Finally, I don’t think this is necessarily an adaptation that many people will want to revisit every Christmas.

And I think that’s a fair criticism.

When people want to get into the Christmas spirit, they’re probably more likely to watch The Muppet Christmas Carol, Scrooged, or Disney’s 2009 adaptation.

This movie almost feels better suited to Halloween, except that its entire story revolves around Christmas.

It’s a strange middle ground.

And unfortunately, I don’t think it entirely succeeds at balancing those two identities.

Final Thoughts

Despite everything I’ve criticized, I want to make one thing perfectly clear.

I still really enjoyed Ebenezer. But I didn’t love it, heck I still prefer the 2009 Jim Carry film and the 1999 Patrick Stewart film.

I appreciate its gothic atmosphere, the frightening supernatural imagery, Johnny Depp’s performance, and several of the changes made to familiar scenes.

And I certainly don’t think it’s an unfaithful adaptation.

Quite the opposite. The movie respects much of Dickens’s original story and introduces some genuinely thoughtful additions.

However, I also think Ti West became so focused on making a dark, horror-oriented version of A Christmas Carol that he occasionally lost sight of what makes the story so special.

It’s not just about frightening a miserable old man into becoming a better person.

It’s about showing him that life is worth celebrating.

It’s about kindness, generosity, companionship, forgiveness, and the joy of Christmas.

And while Ebenezer understands several of those themes, I don’t think it captures the Christmas joy particularly well.

The movie certainly has heart, but it’s buried underneath so much misery that you occasionally have to dig around to find it.

I still consider Disney’s 2009 adaptation my favorite, followed by the 1999 Patrick Stewart version, with Ebenezer coming in third.

And that’s certainly not a bad position to be in, considering how many adaptations of this story exist.

I just wish Ti West had found a better middle ground between the horror and the hope.

Because there’s an excellent Christmas movie buried somewhere underneath all this darkness.

It just needed a little more Christmas spirit. In fact, you may as well just go turn on any of the earlier christmas carol adaptations.

Rating: 7/10

An enjoyable, atmospheric, and largely faithful adaptation with some excellent original additions and genuinely creepy imagery. However, its relentlessly bleak tone, questionable creative decisions, and lack of Christmas joy prevent it from reaching the heights of my favorite adaptations.

—

⚠️ SPOILER WARNING ⚠️

From this point onward, I’ll be discussing specific scenes, character moments, and changes made to Dickens’s original story. If you haven’t seen Ebenezer yet and want to experience these additions for yourself, consider this your warning!

Spoilers

Let’s start with something I found rather interesting.

Instead of opening with Dickens’s famous declaration that Marley was dead, the movie begins seven years earlier, showing Jacob Marley while he was still alive.

We see how he treats Bob Cratchit before eventually dying, establishing just how unpleasant the business was even before Scrooge became its sole owner.

I actually appreciated this addition.

However, I wasn’t particularly fond of Marley’s eventual ghostly appearance.

The design itself is creepy enough, particularly when he removes the bandage around his jaw and his mouth falls open.

But the conversation between Marley and Scrooge is incredibly awkward.

The dialogue moves so quickly that it feels like the actors are simply reading famous lines from the novella rather than responding naturally to one another.

Marley announces that three spirits will visit Scrooge, delivers his dramatic farewell, and disappears.

And I’m sitting there thinking, could we please give this conversation a little room to breathe?

Thankfully, the movie handles some of its other supernatural encounters considerably better.

For example, I really enjoyed Scrooge’s introduction to the Ghost of Christmas Past.

When the spirit first appears in his bedroom, Scrooge refuses to cooperate.

So instead of patiently waiting for him to change his mind, she disappears, his bed starts shaking, and he’s suddenly dragged into the snowy surroundings of his old school.

Scrooge even tries hiding underneath his blanket, apparently hoping that everything will disappear if he ignores it.

I thought that was a genuinely entertaining addition.

However, the spirit herself looks absolutely horrifying.

She’s pale, skeletal, and has these creepy white eyes. Her back looks so emaciated that you’d think she’d been starving for decades.

And I’m sorry, but why does the Ghost of Christmas Past look like she was recently pulled out of a river?!

I appreciate the design from a horror perspective, but I question why this particular spirit needed to look so disturbing.

One of my favorite additions, however, involves Belle.

The movie expands Scrooge’s relationship with her, including a lock of her hair that his younger self burns following their separation.

Watching the older Scrooge desperately beg his younger self to go after Belle was genuinely heartbreaking.

He knows exactly what he’s about to lose, but there’s absolutely nothing he can do to change it.

And when he later sees Belle crying alone, it’s another painful reminder of how much happiness he sacrificed.

Eventually, Scrooge becomes so overwhelmed that he grabs the spirit’s arm, causing her to scream as a burst of light erupts from her face.

Again, creepy as hell!

But I thought the emotional material surrounding Belle was excellent.

The Ghost of Christmas Present also receives a rather interesting introduction.

Instead of simply waiting inside his home, Scrooge actually attempts to escape when the next spirit is due to arrive.

He sees frightening figures outside and eventually hides inside a pub.

And who’s sitting there enjoying an enormous banquet?

The Ghost of Christmas Present!

The spirit casually tells Scrooge that he’s late, and once Scrooge realizes who he’s talking to, everybody else in the pub disappears.

I thought that was a fantastic introduction.

Unfortunately, I’m not nearly as fond of the spirit’s personality.

He’s incredibly stern, impatient, and intimidating.

At one point, he practically orders Scrooge to sit down and shut up.

And while I appreciate the commanding performance, I really miss the cheerful personality that traditionally defines this character.

The spirit is supposed to represent the present joys of Christmas, not act like Scrooge has been summoned to the principal’s office!

However, I did appreciate several of the scenes he shows Scrooge.

One particularly touching moment takes place inside a church, where Tiny Tim struggles to kneel during prayer because of his disability.

After becoming embarrassed, he returns to his seat, and Bob quietly sits beside him so he won’t feel alone.

That was a genuinely beautiful moment.

We also see the Cratchit family struggling financially, with Bob attempting to repair Tiny Tim’s crutch.

Scrooge initially defends the wages he pays Bob, arguing that his employee receives the money they agreed upon.

Naturally, the spirit challenges this attitude, eventually confronting Scrooge with the possibility of Tiny Tim’s death.

Another addition I really enjoyed involves Fred.

During the Christmas gathering, Fred explains that he continues inviting Scrooge because his late mother, Fan, would have wanted him to look after her brother.

Even though Scrooge constantly rejects him, Fred refuses to give up on his uncle.

I thought that was a wonderful way to expand their relationship.

We also discover that Belle has married and now spends time helping impoverished people at a shelter.

Scrooge asks to see her again, and the spirit shows him Belle singing alongside the people she’s helping.

The movie connects this moment with the celebrations taking place among Fred’s guests and the Cratchit family.

It’s one of the few sequences where the movie genuinely attempts to capture the warmth of Christmas.

Unfortunately, things quickly become miserable again.

As the night progresses, the Ghost of Christmas Present begins visibly deteriorating.

His skin cracks, he coughs, and he becomes increasingly frail.

There’s even a moment where he admits that he’s never eaten goose, prompting Scrooge to offer him some.

But it’s too late.

The spirit is dying.

Scrooge places his coat over him, which I thought was a lovely little demonstration of his growing compassion.

However, we then get the appearance of Ignorance and Want.

And GOOD LORD!

Instead of simply emerging from beneath the spirit’s clothing, the children burst out of his ribcage and begin crawling after Scrooge, begging him not to abandon them.

It’s genuinely disturbing.

Scrooge flees into a church, makes his way through the catacombs, and eventually encounters the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come.

Now, I actually like this spirit’s crow-inspired appearance.

The black feathers, hood, and grim-reaper imagery are suitably creepy.

However, I still think the Ghost of Christmas Past is considerably scarier.

And there’s one particular moment that left me scratching my head.

When Scrooge sees the face underneath the spirit’s hood, he discovers his own dead face with coins covering its eyes.

He then reacts by shouting something along the lines of, “YOU! I knew it was you!”

I’m sorry, what?!

Why are we suddenly acting like this is the dramatic reveal of a murder mystery?

The movie never really establishes why Scrooge would recognize the spirit in that manner, so the moment feels rather strange.

And then a crow emerges from the spirit’s mouth, knocking Scrooge backward into an open grave.

Gravediggers proceed to bury him.

Well, that’s certainly one way to traumatize Ebenezer Scrooge!

But one of the most depressing changes comes when the spirit shows Scrooge what happens to Bob Cratchit and his family.

Not only has Tiny Tim died, but the Cratchits are now apparently homeless, living in the same shelter where Belle was previously helping people.

I understand the intention behind this addition.

It demonstrates just how vulnerable Bob’s family is financially and how easily their circumstances could deteriorate.

However, it also reinforces one of my biggest criticisms.

This movie is already so relentlessly miserable that adding even more suffering eventually becomes exhausting.

And it raises the uncomfortable question of what happens to everybody else living in poverty once Scrooge changes his ways.

Thankfully, the movie does give us some genuinely wonderful moments during Scrooge’s redemption.

When Scrooge awakens on Christmas morning, he’s overjoyed to discover that he’s still alive.

He even jumps on his bed, only for it to collapse underneath him.

I’ll admit, I found that joke rather predictable, especially considering how serious the movie had been beforehand.

However, I really enjoyed what follows.

Scrooge discovers that Tiny Tim is ill and arranges for a highly qualified doctor to treat him.

When Bob respectfully refuses to accept charity, Scrooge comes up with a clever solution.

He explains that Bob will pay for the treatment himself, using the substantial raise Scrooge is giving him.

And then comes one of my favorite additions in the entire movie.

Scrooge decides that the old business sign reading “Scrooge and Marley” has served its purpose.

He offers Bob a partnership and announces that the business will now be known as Scrooge and Cratchit.

I absolutely loved that!

It’s a wonderful way of showing that Scrooge no longer views Bob as merely an employee.

He recognizes his value and wants to build something better alongside him.

Another excellent scene involves Scrooge visiting Fred.

He arrives carrying a dead goose in a basket, awkwardly admitting that he wasn’t entirely sure what he was supposed to bring.

I actually found that rather amusing.

But the scene becomes genuinely emotional when Scrooge apologizes for how he’s treated Fred over the years.

He explains that Fred reminds him of his late sister, particularly her smile and kindness.

Scrooge admits that Fan would have been disappointed by how cruelly he treated her son.

And after Fred previously explained that he kept inviting Scrooge because of his mother’s wishes, this scene provides a beautiful emotional payoff.

I also appreciated the conclusion to Belle’s storyline.

We discover that Belle has written a book, and Scrooge eventually purchases a copy.

Rather than attempting to rekindle their relationship, he anonymously sends her the book with a congratulatory message acknowledging the lessons she taught him.

Belle recognizes who sent it, and the moment provides some lovely closure without forcing an unnecessary romantic reunion.

However, I was disappointed by a couple of omissions from the traditional ending.

For starters, Scrooge never returns to the two gentlemen who previously approached him about donating money to the poor.

Considering how heavily this movie emphasizes poverty, I thought that was a particularly strange omission.

The original story gives us the satisfaction of seeing Scrooge make a substantial charitable contribution after previously rejecting them.

Here, that payoff is missing.

And then there’s the actual ending.

Instead of concluding with Tiny Tim’s famous declaration, “God bless us, every one,” the movie ends with Scrooge giving his pocket watch to a homeless elderly man and inviting him inside for tea.

I actually thought that was a lovely gesture.

It demonstrates that Scrooge’s newfound generosity extends beyond his immediate family and employees.

However, I still missed the traditional ending with Tiny Tim.

There’s something so wonderfully uplifting about that final moment, particularly in the 2009 adaptation.

And considering how little Christmas joy this movie provides throughout its runtime, I really think it could have benefited from a more celebratory conclusion.

Instead, we get another relatively quiet moment of kindness before a crow flies away and the movie ends.

Again, it’s not a bad ending.

But I don’t think it delivers the same emotional satisfaction.

And ultimately, that’s how I feel about Ebenezer as a whole.

There are some genuinely excellent additions here, and I appreciate that Ti West wasn’t afraid to explore the frightening elements of Dickens’s story.

But for every great idea, there’s another decision that leaves me wondering what the filmmakers were thinking.

The horror is effective, the performances are largely enjoyable, and the story remains recognizable.

However, the movie seems so fascinated by death, suffering, and misery that it occasionally forgets the happiness Scrooge is supposed to discover.

And that’s a shame.

Because A Christmas Carol isn’t simply about showing a miserable old man how terrible the world can be.

It’s about showing him how wonderful life can become when he finally opens his heart to other people. Also side tangent about to happen.

When Being Kind Apparently Gets You Killed: How Ebenezer Undermines the Entire Point of Dickens’s Story

Now, here’s something that didn’t fully hit me until after watching the movie, and the more I think about it, the more it genuinely pisses me off. For a movie based on one of the most famous stories ever written about generosity, compassion, and the importance of helping those less fortunate than yourself, Ebenezer makes some incredibly questionable decisions that almost seem to undermine the entire message Charles Dickens was trying to convey. And I’m not talking about the ghosts looking like they crawled out of a Victorian morgue. I’m talking about the actual morality of the story!

Let’s start with good old Mr. Fezziwig. You know, Scrooge’s former employer? The cheerful, generous, kindhearted man who throws that wonderful Christmas party where young Ebenezer meets Belle? In the original novella, Fezziwig represents everything Scrooge has forgotten about being a decent human being. He’s a businessman who understands that money isn’t everything and that treating your employees with kindness can mean more than any amount of wealth. He’s essentially a walking reminder that you can be successful without being a miserable, greedy asshole.

Well, apparently, Ti West looked at this character and thought, “You know what this story needs? Let’s have Fezziwig get stabbed to death in an alleyway!”

YES. I’M SERIOUS.

During the Ghost of Christmas Past’s visit, Scrooge reminisces about Fezziwig and his famous Christmas party. But then we learn that Fezziwig was murdered after generously giving money to homeless people. And Scrooge actually uses this tragedy to justify his own bitterness, essentially arguing that this is what happens to people who are too kindhearted.

EXCUSE ME?!

Now, I can understand what the writers were probably going for here. Maybe they wanted to give Scrooge another reason for becoming such a cynical, miserable old bastard. Perhaps watching a genuinely good man meet such a horrible end convinced him that kindness makes people vulnerable and that generosity only gets you taken advantage of. As a character motivation, I can see the potential. There’s actually something interesting there.

But here’s the problem: this is supposed to be A Christmas Carol, not a cautionary tale about why you should never give a homeless person five pounds!

Fezziwig’s importance in Dickens’s novella isn’t that his kindness eventually gets him killed. It’s that his kindness makes a difference. He makes people happy. He treats his employees with dignity. He demonstrates that generosity isn’t measured by how much money you spend but by the happiness you bring to others. And most importantly, his example helps Scrooge recognize just how badly he’s been treating Bob Cratchit.

By giving Fezziwig such a gruesome fate, the movie introduces an incredibly cynical implication. Here was a man who genuinely cared about people less fortunate than himself, and what did that get him? A knife in the back and a corpse in an alleyway. Merry Christmas, everybody!

Seriously, what is the morality of the story? If you are a beggar, then don’t be nice to them because they might stab you In the back? What a wholesome message for the whole family.

And it gets worse when you consider how the movie handles charity elsewhere. Instead of simply showing charitable collectors as decent people trying to help the poor, the film introduces dishonesty and corruption into that side of the story as well. So now we’re getting a version of A Christmas Carol where Scrooge’s suspicions about helping strangers aren’t necessarily being challenged. In some cases, the screenplay seems almost determined to prove him right!

That’s a pretty serious problem when the entire point of the original story is that Scrooge needs to stop viewing the poor as a burden on society and start recognizing them as fellow human beings deserving of compassion.

But you know what? The Fezziwig situation isn’t even the most baffling part. Because when we finally reach the ending and Scrooge has his big Christmas morning transformation, the movie creates an entirely different problem.

Who the hell is Scrooge actually helping?

Let’s examine this, shall we?

First, we have Fred, Scrooge’s nephew. Scrooge finally reconnects with him, apologizes for his behavior, and gives him the uncle he’s been missing all these years. Wonderful! That’s genuinely touching, and I loved that scene.

Then there’s Bob Cratchit. Scrooge arranges medical treatment for Tiny Tim, gives Bob a long-overdue raise, and even offers him a partnership in the business. He goes so far as to change the company’s name from Scrooge and Marley to Scrooge and Cratchit. Again, fantastic! I thought that was one of the movie’s best additions, and it gives Bob a much more satisfying ending than simply receiving a little extra money.

Then there’s Belle, Scrooge’s former fiancée. He purchases her published novel and sends her a thoughtful message congratulating her on her accomplishments. It’s a beautiful little moment that shows Scrooge finally appreciating someone he once pushed away.

So far, so good!

But notice something about all three of these people?

SCROOGE ALREADY KNOWS THEM!

Fred is his nephew. Bob is his employee. Belle is the woman he once loved.

Now, I’m not saying these gestures are meaningless. Far from it. They’re some of my favorite moments in the entire movie. But what about everyone else? What about the countless impoverished people we’ve spent the entire film watching suffer? What about the homeless families, the starving children, and the people struggling to survive in this absolutely miserable depiction of Victorian London?

Well, don’t worry, everybody! Ebenezer Scrooge has finally learned the true meaning of Christmas! Or has he? Idk.

And how does he demonstrate his newfound generosity toward someone outside his immediate circle?

HE GIVES A HOMELESS MAN HIS POCKET WATCH AND INVITES HIM OVER FOR TEA!

WOW! SOMEBODY CALL THE NEWSPAPERS! WHAT A CHRISTMAS MIRACLE!

Now, don’t misunderstand me. Inviting a homeless stranger into your home is a kind gesture, especially coming from someone who previously wanted absolutely nothing to do with the poor. And giving away something personally valuable can certainly be meaningful.

But COME ON!

We’ve spent this entire movie being beaten over the head with how absolutely horrific poverty is. We’ve seen homeless shelters, desperate families, and people living in conditions that make you wonder how anyone survived Victorian London in the first place. The movie even goes so far as to show the Cratchits becoming homeless after Tiny Tim’s death in the future.

And after ALL OF THAT, the grand demonstration of Scrooge’s generosity toward the wider community is a pocket watch and a cup of tea?

WHAT HAPPENS AFTER TEATIME, EBENEZER?!

Does the man get a place to stay? Does Scrooge offer him employment? Does he help him find permanent shelter? Does he contribute to the organizations trying to help people like him?

The movie doesn’t give us much of an answer.

For all we know, the poor bastard finishes his tea, thanks Scrooge for his hospitality, and heads straight back into the freezing London streets!

“Well, thank you for the lovely afternoon, Mr. Scrooge. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I must return to being homeless. Merry Christmas!”

And here’s where this becomes especially frustrating: Dickens already provided the perfect solution to this problem in the original novella!

Remember those two gentlemen who visit Scrooge at the beginning of the story asking for charitable donations? The ones Scrooge dismisses while making his infamous remarks about prisons, workhouses, and the surplus population?

Well, after his transformation, Scrooge encounters one of those gentlemen again and offers a substantial donation. We don’t even need to know the exact amount. The man’s astonished reaction tells us everything we need to know.

That moment is incredibly important because it demonstrates something beyond Scrooge simply becoming nicer to his relatives and employees. It shows that he finally recognizes his responsibility toward people he doesn’t personally know.

THAT IS THE ENTIRE BLOODY POINT!

Dickens wasn’t simply writing a story about a grumpy uncle learning to attend family dinners. He was criticizing a society that treated poverty as a personal failure and viewed the suffering of the poor as somebody else’s problem. Scrooge’s transformation represents a rejection of that worldview.

He doesn’t suddenly solve every social problem in London, nor does Dickens pretend that one wealthy man’s generosity can magically eliminate poverty. But he does become someone willing to use his wealth and influence to make life better for others.

And that’s what makes the 2026 movie’s approach so bizarre.

The filmmakers dramatically expand the amount of poverty and suffering we’re shown, yet the ending gives surprisingly little attention to Scrooge doing anything substantial about that wider suffering.

Think about how easily they could have fixed this! They already established Belle working at a homeless shelter. Why not have Scrooge make a significant donation to that shelter? Why not show him providing food, clothing, or accommodation for some of the people we’ve spent the entire movie watching struggle? Why not bring back the charitable collectors in a way that reinforces the importance of genuine generosity?

You wouldn’t even need an additional ten minutes. One meaningful scene could have tied the movie’s expanded poverty storyline directly into Scrooge’s redemption.

Instead, we get a pocket watch.

And this is where the Fezziwig situation comes back to bite the screenplay in the ass.

Because when you combine these two decisions, the movie starts sending a rather uncomfortable message, whether intentionally or not.

Fezziwig generously helps homeless strangers and gets murdered for his trouble.

Scrooge becomes a better person and directs most of his meaningful generosity toward his nephew, his employee, and his former fiancée.

So what’s the lesson here?

Be kind to others, but preferably only to your close friends and family. And whatever you do, don’t be too generous to strangers, because apparently that’s how you end up dead in an alleyway!

WHAT KIND OF CHRISTMAS MESSAGE IS THAT?!

And again, I don’t believe that’s what Ti West and the writers consciously intended. I suspect Fezziwig’s murder was supposed to illustrate Scrooge’s deeply flawed understanding of kindness, while the ending was intended to demonstrate how much he’s changed.

But there’s a difference between what a movie wants to communicate and what its actual storytelling decisions end up suggesting.

And unfortunately, Ebenezer creates a contradiction that becomes harder to ignore the more you think about it.

This is especially disappointing because I genuinely liked the movie! I gave it an 8/10, and I stand by that rating. There are some excellent performances, beautiful Gothic visuals, genuinely creative additions, and emotional moments that I thought worked wonderfully.

But I can enjoy those things while still recognizing that the screenplay occasionally loses sight of what made Dickens’s story so powerful in the first place.

The original A Christmas Carol is dark. It’s frightening. It deals with death, regret, loneliness, poverty, and the consequences of living a selfish life. Dickens wasn’t afraid to confront the ugliness of Victorian society.

But he also understood something that this movie occasionally seems to forget.

The darkness exists to make the eventual light shine brighter.

The point isn’t that the world is horrible, generosity gets you killed, and the best you can do is take care of the handful of people you already know.

The point is that even in a cruel, unequal world, kindness matters. Compassion matters. Helping strangers matters. And someone who has spent their entire life contributing to that cruelty can still choose to become part of the solution.

That’s why Scrooge’s redemption is supposed to feel so uplifting.

And that’s ultimately what frustrates me about Ebenezer. The movie spends so much time emphasizing how terrible the world is that, when it finally comes time to show us how one man can make that world a little better, it seems strangely hesitant to follow through.

Charles Dickens wrote a story about a man learning to open his heart to humanity. Ti West gives us a man who mostly opens his heart to people already in his address book.

And for a movie called Ebenezer, based on A Christmas Carol, that’s a pretty damn significant problem.

Despite my criticisms, I still enjoyed the movie and consider it one of my favorite adaptations.

I just wish Ti West had remembered that sometimes the most powerful thing you can put in a dark Christmas story isn’t another frightening ghost.

It’s a little bit of Christmas joy, and to not make poor people look like bad guys.

Final Rating: 7/10

Leave a Reply