Monster: The Lizzie Borden 🩸 (2026) Review
Netflix Took an Axe to History and Gave It More Than 40 Whacks
⚠️ Content Warning
Before we go any further, I want to give everyone a serious warning about the content in Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story. This warning contains no plot spoilers.
This series contains extremely graphic violence and gore, including brutal axe attacks, mutilated bodies, severe facial injuries, prolonged blood imagery, and disturbing crime-scene material. It also contains graphic sexual violence, including rape, sexual content, prostitution, abusive and dysfunctional family relationships, misogyny, xenophobia, substance use, execution imagery, menstruation and other bodily-blood imagery, as well as animal death and distress.
Some of these sequences are deliberately prolonged and visually explicit rather than merely implied off-screen. The series also dramatizes real murders and real historical people, which may make some of the material considerably more disturbing for certain viewers.
So please keep all of that in mind before deciding whether this is something you want to watch.
Well, here we are again. Another season of Monster. Another real-world case. Another collection of actual human beings being shoved through the Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan dramatization machine until what comes out the other side sometimes bears only a passing resemblance to the historical record.
Before I get into Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, I need to make something extremely clear: I have never been a fan of Ryan Murphy’s Netflix Monster universe. In fact, I despise it. I didn’t like what this franchise did with Jeffrey Dahmer. I didn’t like what it did with the Menendez brothers. I didn’t like what it did with Ed Gein. And four seasons in, I am completely exhausted by this franchise taking real crimes, real victims, real suspects, and real human suffering and reshaping them into whatever heightened drama it wants to tell that year.
And before somebody tells me that historical dramas always take creative liberties: I know. Obviously, you cannot know every private conversation that happened more than a century ago. You sometimes have to condense timelines, combine information, and create dialogue. My problem isn’t that every sentence spoken in this show cannot be authenticated by a historian.
My problem is when “creative liberty” becomes creative replacement.
And good God, does The Lizzie Borden Story cross that line for me.
At least Netflix openly acknowledges that this is a fictionalized interpretation. I’ll give them that microscopic crumb of credit. They’re not pretending everything you’re about to watch has been proven historical fact.
But that leads me to another question:
If you’re going to change this much of the history, why are we telling the Lizzie Borden story at all?
Also heres a fun fact about me, I first heard of the Lizzie Borden case thanks to a episode from The Most Terrifying Places In America, yes thats where I first heard about this case.
Let’s start by showing y’all the trailers shall we?
The marketing made it pretty clear what kind of interpretation we were getting this time around. This wasn’t being sold primarily as a careful examination of one of America’s most enduring unsolved murder mysteries. It was being presented as a story of female repression, rage, sexuality, revenge, and liberation.
Netflix’s own description talks about a repressed daughter and rebellious maid escaping into a fantasy of sex, power, and revenge before gruesome murders create an icon who refuses to remain imprisoned.
And that right there represents one of my biggest issues with this entire season.
The real Lizzie Borden case already has an incredible hook:
Did Lizzie Borden actually do it?
She was accused.
She was tried.
She was acquitted.
Andrew and Abby Borden’s murders remain officially unsolved.
More than 130 years later, historians still debate what happened inside that house.
Apparently that wasn’t interesting enough.
Non-Spoiler Plot Overview
Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story is the fourth installment of Netflix’s Monster anthology and follows Lizzie Borden, played by Ella Beatty, as she lives with her wealthy but deeply dysfunctional family in Fall River, Massachusetts.
Lizzie exists in an oppressive household dominated by her father Andrew, played by Charlie Hunnam, and her stepmother Abby, played by Rebecca Hall. Her life begins changing dramatically with the arrival of Bridget “Maggie” Sullivan, played by Vicky Krieps, the family’s new maid.
The show’s version of Bridget is worldly, rebellious, sexually liberated, and fiercely independent. She exposes the sheltered Lizzie to ideas about female autonomy, sexuality, historical women, and freedom from the expectations placed upon her.
Their relationship becomes the emotional center of the season as Lizzie begins questioning the world around her and increasingly embracing the rage that she has spent years repressing.
Eventually, of course, we reach August 4, 1892, when Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally murdered inside their home.
And if you’re expecting the series to become a complicated whodunit examining the evidence and allowing us to question whether Lizzie was responsible?
HAHAHAHA.
No.
But that’s spoiler territory.
The series consists of eight episodes and also incorporates other infamous women from history, most notably Elizabeth Báthory and Aileen Wuornos, as part of its broader attempt to examine female rage across different eras.
Whether that adds anything meaningful is something we’ll be discussing extensively.
And by “discussing,” I mean I have questions. So many fucking questions.
Character Rundown
Lizzie Borden – Ella Beatty
Lizzie is obviously our central character. Rather than portraying her primarily as the unknowable woman at the center of an unsolved crime, the series constructs a psychological journey for her. She’s sheltered, sexually inexperienced, frustrated by Victorian expectations, and increasingly desperate to escape her household.
Ella Beatty certainly commits to the material, and the performance isn’t my fundamental issue here.
My issue is who this version of Lizzie actually is.
The real Lizzie was 32 years old at the time of the murders. She was involved with her church and the Women’s Christian Temperance Union, and there were genuine tensions within the Borden family, particularly involving money and Lizzie’s relationship with Abby.
But the series takes those fragments and constructs an enormously elaborate explanation for Lizzie’s psychology.
And because the show wants Lizzie to embody female repression and rage, almost everyone around her gets reshaped to facilitate that interpretation.
Bridget “Maggie” Sullivan – Vicky Krieps
Probably the most radically reinvented major character.
The show’s Bridget is an Irish-German, worldly traveler and rebellious feminist who becomes Lizzie’s mentor, awakening her politically, emotionally, and sexually.
The actual Bridget Sullivan was a 26-year-old Irish immigrant working as the Borden family’s maid.
There is no established historical evidence that she was Lizzie’s lover.
There is no established evidence that she was Lizzie’s feminist mentor.
There is no established evidence that she helped Lizzie murder anybody.
Historian Cara Robertson’s research even describes Bridget as remaining in the household partly because she was loyal to Abby, whom Bridget reportedly called “a lovely woman.”
So yes, the character works within the story Monster has invented.
I’m just increasingly unsure what that character has to do with Bridget Sullivan beyond borrowing her name and occupation.
Andrew Borden – Charlie Hunnam
Andrew is Lizzie’s wealthy and emotionally distant father. The show emphasizes his frugality, strange behavior, obsession with axes, and dysfunctional relationships with the women surrounding him.
Charlie Hunnam gives the character plenty of presence, but once again, the series exaggerates historical material into grotesque imagery.
The real Andrew was involved in furniture and casket-making.
The series takes that and gives us Andrew chopping the feet off corpses because they don’t fit inside coffins.
There is no historical evidence that he did this.
Because apparently merely selling coffins wasn’t sufficiently creepy.
Abby Borden – Rebecca Hall
Rebecca Hall is one of the strongest performers here, but Abby might also be one of the clearest examples of the show turning a historical person into what the script needs.
There really was tension between Lizzie and Abby. Lizzie and Emma became resentful after Andrew transferred property to Abby’s family.
That’s history.
But Monster transforms Abby into an enormously cruel and abusive stepmother.
And that matters because if your thesis is that Lizzie’s eventual rage grew out of years of oppression, making her family considerably more monstrous helps justify the story you’ve already decided to tell.
Again:
Dramatizing history isn’t the problem. Reshaping history to support your predetermined explanation is.
Emma Borden – Billie Lourd
Emma is Lizzie’s older sister and another important part of the family dynamic. The real Emma was away when the murders occurred and supported Lizzie during the aftermath and trial.
The series uses her relationship with Lizzie to explore loyalty, family obligation, suspicion, and eventually the deterioration of their relationship.
Their real-life relationship did eventually collapse. Emma left the Maplecroft mansion in 1905 and the sisters never reconciled.
Why?
We don’t definitively know.
You may have noticed that “we don’t definitively know” keeps appearing throughout this review.
Somebody should have told the writers.
Nance O’Neil – Jessica Barden
Nance was a real actress who became close friends with Lizzie.
The problem is the timeline.
Lizzie didn’t become friends with Nance until years after the trial. The series moves her into Lizzie’s life earlier and uses her as another symbol of female independence and freedom.
Rumors have long existed that Lizzie and Nance might have had a romantic relationship, but that has never been conclusively established either.
John Morse – Joey Pollari
Lizzie’s maternal uncle, who was actually present at the Borden home around the time of the murders.
He has long been part of theories surrounding the case because of his presence and unusually detailed alibi, although historians have never established that he committed the murders.
Naturally, Monster also finds considerably more melodrama for him.
Aileen Wuornos – Sarah Paulson
Yes.
Aileen Wuornos.
In the Lizzie Borden show.
We’ll get there.
Ohhhh, we’ll get there.
Pacing / Episode Flow
The season runs eight episodes, and structurally it feels like several different shows fighting for control.
Early episodes establish Lizzie’s oppressive household, Bridget’s arrival, their growing relationship, the themes of female repression and the historical mythology surrounding women who kill.
Then the series moves increasingly toward violence before transitioning into the investigation, trial and aftermath.
On paper, that’s a perfectly logical progression.
The problem is everything Monster keeps bolting onto it.
We have Elizabeth Báthory sequences.
We have Aileen Wuornos material.
We have stylized fantasy sequences.
We have modern music.
We have exaggerated family melodrama.
We have sexual awakening.
We have historical revisionism.
We have courtroom material.
We have true crime.
We have dark comedy.
We have graphic exploitation.
Pick a lane!
Actually, forget picking a lane. This thing drove through the median, hit three traffic cones, and started heading toward another highway.
And there’s a frustrating irony here: the actual Borden investigation and trial could have supported eight episodes by themselves.
There is so much genuine uncertainty and strange evidence surrounding this case that you wouldn’t need all these side excursions.
Pros
I’m not giving this thing a 2/10 and pretending absolutely nobody involved possesses talent.
The cast is stacked. Ella Beatty commits completely to this interpretation of Lizzie. Vicky Krieps has strong chemistry with her. Rebecca Hall brings considerable weight to Abby, and Sarah Paulson remains an excellent performer even though I question why Aileen Wuornos belongs anywhere near this narrative.
The production itself also looks expensive and deliberately stylized. The period sets, costumes, gothic imagery and cinematography have received deserved praise.
There are also genuine historical details scattered throughout the season. Lizzie really was acquitted. There really were major tensions surrounding property and inheritance. Her inconsistent testimony and morphine use are relevant to the historical record. The infamous burned dress is real. Bridget really was called “Maggie” by members of the household. Emma really was away when the murders occurred. Lizzie and Emma really did eventually become estranged.
And Netflix deserves one extremely tiny gold star for openly treating the program as fictionalized.
⭐
There.
Enjoy it.
That’s about as charitable as I’m getting.
Cons
Where the fuck do I begin?
My largest problem is that Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story takes an unsolved murder case and solves it through fiction.
You want to know whether Lizzie Borden killed Andrew and Abby?
Historically?
We don’t know.
Michael Martins, curator of the Fall River Historical Society and an expert on the case, has openly said he doesn’t know who committed the murders and doesn’t think anybody ever will.
Cara Robertson spent years researching the trial and doesn’t pretend she can definitively solve it either.
Ian Brennan, meanwhile, has said his research left him finding it very difficult to believe Lizzie didn’t commit the crime.
Okay.
That’s his interpretation.
But Monster doesn’t merely explore that interpretation.
It commits to it.
And that’s such a waste of the most interesting thing about this case.
Imagine a version where every episode shifts your opinion.
Episode two makes Lizzie look guilty as hell.
Episode three introduces something that creates reasonable doubt.
Episode four makes Bridget suspicious.
Episode five introduces the financial motive.
Episode six dismantles something you thought you understood.
Then Lizzie gets acquitted and the series ends without telling you what happened.
You’d be arguing about it afterward.
Instead, Monster basically goes:
“Nah, she fucking did it.”
Well, thanks.
Mystery solved, everybody!
Pack up the history books!
Then there’s the larger Monster problem.
I have never been a fan of Ryan Murphy’s Netflix Monster universe.
Actually, “not a fan” is hilariously inadequate.
I despise this franchise.
Four seasons in, I’m tired of seeing actual crimes repeatedly turned into these sensationalized dramas where historical reality sometimes seems less important than whatever psychological, sexual or thematic idea Murphy and Brennan want to explore.
And yes, Ian Brennan wrote all eight episodes of this particular season. I’m not blaming every creative decision exclusively on Murphy.
But this franchise has developed a recognizable approach, and I cannot stand it.
At some point I have to ask:
Why are we using real people’s names?
If you want to make a gothic lesbian horror series about a sheltered Victorian woman falling in love with her rebellious maid and discovering murderous rage?
MAKE THAT SHOW.
I’d probably have considerably fewer objections!
Call her Elizabeth Gordon.
Have Elizabeth Gordon take an axe.
Give Elizabeth Gordon eighty-seven whacks if you want.
Go nuts.
But when you call her Lizzie Borden, Bridget Sullivan becomes her lover and accomplice, Andrew becomes a corpse-mutilating coffin salesman, Abby becomes an abusive nightmare, Nance O’Neil gets moved around the timeline and another real murder gets attributed to Lizzie?
We’re not filling gaps anymore.
We’re writing historical fanfiction.
And then there’s the show’s attempt to connect Elizabeth Báthory, Lizzie Borden and Aileen Wuornos through this broad concept of female rage.
These were completely different women.
Different centuries.
Different circumstances.
Different evidence.
Different crimes.
Hell, even the historical accounts of Báthory’s crimes remain disputed.
Reducing all of that into a thematic lineage of oppressed women becoming violent doesn’t automatically become profound because you play dramatic music over it.
Sometimes a metaphor isn’t deep.
Sometimes it’s just three completely different stories wearing the same hat.
Final Thoughts
Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story represents almost everything I dislike about this franchise.
There was a fascinating series sitting right there.
Tell me about Fall River in 1892.
Tell me about the Borden household.
Tell me what we actually know about Andrew and Abby.
Show me the murders without identifying the killer.
Take me through Lizzie’s contradictory statements.
Show me the investigation.
Show me the prosecution’s case.
Show me the defense.
Show me why an all-male jury acquitted her.
Show me how Victorian assumptions about women influenced people’s interpretation of the evidence.
Show me why people still believe Lizzie was guilty.
Then show me why other people believe the prosecution never proved its case.
Let me decide.
Instead, Monster wants to decide for me and then construct an elaborate psychosexual explanation around that decision.
And perhaps the most frustrating part is that there are genuinely interesting ideas buried inside this thing.
How did Victorian society perceive female violence?
Why did Lizzie become an American folk legend?
Why has a woman acquitted of murder remained culturally synonymous with the crime?
How does misogyny affect both the demonization and infantilization of accused women?
How does sensationalized storytelling gradually replace historical fact?
That last question is particularly ironic because this series itself becomes a fantastic example. Plz Netflix stop, stop supporting Ryan Murphy and his delusional writing.
Rating
1/10
This isn’t getting a 2/10 as i originally planned, because I despise the director so much and Netflix for indulging this guy, fuck you Ryan Murphy and fuck you Netflix for giving him Carte Blanche.
Also the fact that this franchise, ughhhh
Is called the monster universe
Go fuck off
Not eveything nerds to be a cinematic universe, especially around real world killers
Whats next? We gonna combine them together in a avengers styled film where they fight against their biggest threat yet? Bureaucracy
The acting prevents me from going lower.
The production values prevent me from going lower.
The handful of accurate historical details prevent me from going lower.
But as a dramatization of the Lizzie Borden case?
No.
I cannot get behind this.
Four seasons into Monster, I’m not surprised anymore.
I’m just exhausted.
—
⚠️ Spoiler Warning ⚠️
From this point onward, I’m discussing the entire season, including the murders, who the series depicts as responsible, later deaths, the trial, the ending and the Aileen Wuornos storyline.
Also, separate from spoilers, this series contains extremely graphic axe violence and gore, mutilated bodies and faces, sexual violence including rape, abusive family dynamics, misogyny, xenophobia, explicit sexual material, menstruation and heavy blood imagery, prostitution, execution imagery, substance use, animal death/distress and disturbing material involving real-world murders.
This is considerably more graphic than simply hearing the words “Lizzie Borden took an axe.”
You have been warned.
Spoilers
Okay.
NOW WE CAN REALLY TALK ABOUT THIS FUCKING THING.
The series opens by showing Lizzie murdering Abby and Andrew.
We’re basically minutes into the show and one of history’s most famous unanswered questions has already been answered.
Yes. Lizzie did it.
Great!
Well, I guess we can fuck nuance.
And here’s where I need to clarify something before somebody misunderstands my argument.
I’m not saying Lizzie was innocent.
She very well could have killed them.
There is legitimate evidence that makes her suspicious as hell.
She was present at the house.
Her statements weren’t always consistent.
There was testimony concerning her attempt to obtain prussic acid.
She burned a dress shortly after the murders.
She had financial grievances involving her father and stepmother.
There are perfectly legitimate reasons people have suspected Lizzie for more than 130 years.
But suspicion isn’t proof.
She was tried.
She was acquitted.
Nobody subsequently proved who killed Andrew and Abby.
That’s what makes the story interesting!
And somehow Monster looks at one of America’s greatest murder mysteries and says:
“You know what this needs? Less mystery.”
Bridget and Lizzie
This is where the historical fanfiction really takes off.
The series makes Bridget and Lizzie lovers.
Not merely lovers, either.
Bridget essentially becomes Lizzie’s guide into another world.
She teaches her about sexuality.
She exposes her to feminist ideas.
She introduces her to stories of violent women.
She helps awaken Lizzie’s rebellious side.
And eventually?
She’s her murder accomplice.
There is no historical evidence establishing this relationship.
The actual Bridget Sullivan testified about what happened inside the house and was an important witness.
She eventually left the Bordens behind.
So Monster essentially takes a real woman who was present during an infamous unsolved double murder and says:
“What if she helped?”
That’s an enormous accusation to manufacture around a historical person.
And yes, Netflix calls this fictionalized.
Again:
⭐
There’s your gold star.
Doesn’t mean I have to like it.
Elizabeth Báthory
Bridget introduces Lizzie to Elizabeth Báthory, who becomes this historical symbol of female violence and rebellion.
Except even Báthory’s legend is complicated.
The stories about hundreds of murdered girls and bathing in their blood have been heavily debated by historians.
So now we’ve got:
A fictionalized Bridget telling a fictionalized Lizzie sensationalized stories about another historically disputed woman.
It’s historical uncertainty all the way down!
And somehow this is supposed to help establish the season’s grand thesis about female rage.
Then we get cherry juice baths and modern music and this heightened gothic fantasy aesthetic.
And I’m sitting here thinking:
Was the actual fucking Lizzie Borden case not interesting enough!?
The Poisoning Attempt
The series has Lizzie and Bridget attempting to poison Andrew and Abby using oysters.
The Borden family really did experience gastrointestinal illness shortly before the murders.
But there is no established evidence that Lizzie and Bridget deliberately poisoned them with oysters.
Once again, the show finds an uncertainty and fills it with:
MURDER PLOT.
Because apparently ambiguity has been banned from the building.
Bertha Manchester
Okay.
This one pisses me off.
Bertha Manchester was a real woman.
She was murdered.
The show turns her into someone who abuses Bridget and eventually becomes Lizzie’s practice kill before Andrew and Abby.
Lizzie murders Bertha so she and Bridget can essentially prepare themselves for what they’re planning.
There’s just one teeny-tiny problem.
BERTHA MANCHESTER WAS MURDERED IN MAY 1893.
The Borden murders happened on August 4, 1892.
Bertha died afterward.
Lizzie was already heading toward trial.
Bertha had no established connection to the Bordens.
A Portuguese farmhand was arrested for her murder.
So the writers didn’t merely invent a private conversation.
They didn’t merely speculate about someone’s motivation.
They took the real murder of a real woman, moved it backward through time, connected her to Bridget, and made Lizzie Borden murder her as a fucking practice run.
WHAT?!
This is exactly what I’m talking about when I say there’s a difference between creative liberty and replacing history.
Imagine being Bertha Manchester.
You get murdered.
More than 130 years later Netflix comes along and goes:
“Okay, but what if Lizzie Borden did it?”
WHY?!
You already have TWO UNSOLVED MURDERS!
How many fucking axe murders did this screenplay need?!
Abby’s Murder
Then we finally reach Abby.
The series portrays Lizzie and Bridget as having planned the murders, and Lizzie brutally kills Abby after their already hostile relationship reaches its breaking point.
And because Monster has spent hours transforming Abby into this abusive nightmare, the killing becomes tangled up in the season’s liberation narrative.
That’s where I become especially uncomfortable with the whole female rage thesis.
You can explore how oppression creates anger without turning murder into this grotesque symbol of empowerment.
Because Abby Borden was a real murder victim.
Whatever tensions existed in that household, we do not have evidence supporting the cartoonishly abusive version of Abby the series constructs.
She was struck repeatedly in the head and left dead on the floor of her own home.
Maybe don’t turn that into a fucking liberation fantasy?
Andrew’s Murder
Andrew gets the same treatment.
Bridget takes the initial blow, Lizzie joins in, and the series constructs a two-woman explanation for the Borden killings.
Again:
There is no evidence proving Bridget Sullivan participated in these murders.
The historical mystery has now been replaced with:
Lizzie did it.
Bridget helped.
Here’s their motive.
Here’s their relationship.
Here’s how they planned it.
Here’s another person Lizzie murdered beforehand.
At this point we’re not solving historical gaps.
We’re filling the Grand Canyon with fanfiction.
The Trial
The trial should have been where this series absolutely came alive.
The real trial was sensational.
Lizzie’s inconsistent statements mattered.
The prosecution had circumstantial evidence.
The defense had serious weaknesses to attack.
Victorian gender expectations mattered enormously.
There was no conclusive murder weapon.
There was no confession.
And conviction meant death.
That’s GREAT courtroom drama!
But because we’ve already watched Lizzie commit the murders, the trial isn’t asking us whether she did it.
We’re just watching whether she’s going to get away with something the audience knows she did.
That’s an entirely different story.
And yes, Lizzie is ultimately acquitted, just as she was historically.
The difference is that history leaves us with:
Was an innocent woman correctly acquitted?
or
Did a murderer escape conviction?
Monster leaves us with:
A murderer escaped conviction.
Well, thanks again.
Nance O’Neil
Then there’s Nance.
The real Nance O’Neil became friends with Lizzie years after the trial.
The series moves her earlier and uses her as another representation of liberated femininity.
Because apparently every woman who enters Lizzie’s orbit needs to teach her another lesson from the Monster Guide to Becoming a Victorian Girlboss.
And I want to stress that rumors concerning Lizzie’s sexuality have existed for a long time. I’m not complaining simply because the show depicts Lizzie as queer.
My problem is presenting speculative relationships and heavily altered timelines as the emotional skeleton supporting the entire narrative.
Those are very different criticisms.
Emma
Emma eventually leaves Lizzie.
Historically, that much happened.
The sisters lived together at Maplecroft before Emma left in 1905 and never reconciled with Lizzie.
But historians do not definitively know what caused their falling-out.
Naturally, Monster provides answers because apparently “we don’t know” causes these writers physical pain.
The actual uncertainty surrounding Emma and Lizzie is fascinating.
Something happened.
We don’t know exactly what.
That’s haunting.
You don’t need to fix it!
WHY THE FUCK IS AILEEN WUORNOS HERE?
Okay.
Here we go.
Sarah Paulson plays Aileen Wuornos.
Why?
Because the series wants to connect Elizabeth Báthory to Lizzie Borden to Aileen Wuornos as this lineage of violent women and female rage.
Ian Brennan has explained that the intention was to show that female rage wasn’t some isolated historical event and that the repression underlying it continues into modern society.
I understand the thesis.
I hate the execution.
Aileen becomes fascinated with Lizzie.
She uses Lizzie’s name.
She visits the real Lizzie Borden Bed & Breakfast.
We recreate parts of Aileen’s horrific life.
We recreate her sexual assault.
We recreate her trial.
We recreate her execution.
And eventually, after Aileen is executed?
WE GET FUCKING AFTERLIFE LIZZIE BORDEN.
Aileen sees Lizzie and Bridget/Maggie.
Lizzie tells her:
“All is forgiven. All is understood.”
WHAT!?
Who is forgiving whom?!
Why is Lizzie Borden apparently running the afterlife customer-service desk for executed serial killers?!
And this is where Vulture’s criticism absolutely nails the problem: what does any of this teach us about Lizzie Borden?
Nothing.
We’ve simply dragged another real woman’s horrifying life and real victims into this series because the writers wanted a thematic parallel.
Aileen Wuornos isn’t a metaphor.
She’s not a fictional character you can summon into your story whenever you need another example of “female rage.”
She was a real person who murdered real people.
And her history is complicated enough without turning her into the spiritual descendant of your fictionalized Lizzie Borden.
The Ending
Eventually Maggie returns to Lizzie after an unhappy marriage in Ireland, and the two women reunite romantically.
The series pushes Lizzie further into its interpretation as a woman who broke free from her cage, and it even associates Lizzie and Maggie with the women’s suffrage movement.
Except there is no historical evidence that Lizzie Borden was a suffragette.
Because apparently we hadn’t fictionalized enough yet.
By the end, the historical Lizzie Borden has almost disappeared completely.
What remains is the character Monster wanted:
A sexually repressed woman.
Awakened by a worldly lover.
Oppressed by monstrous parents.
Inspired by legendary female killers.
Driven toward murder.
Liberated through violence.
Acquitted.
Reunited with her lover.
Connected spiritually to future female murderers.
That’s not an interpretation filling gaps around Lizzie Borden.
That’s an original gothic antihero wearing Lizzie Borden’s nametag.
And that’s ultimately why I landed at 2/10.
I don’t care how beautiful your cinematography is.
I don’t care how talented your actors are.
I don’t care how much blood you spray across the screen.
If you’re going to use real history, then I need to feel like the history matters to you beyond being a convenient foundation for the story you actually wanted to tell.
And after four seasons of Monster, I am beyond tired of this approach.
Maybe someday this franchise will surprise me.
But Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story certainly didn’t.
2/10.
Now please, for the love of God, leave some historical mysteries mysterious.
