🎅 The Santa Clause 2 (2002) Review

Let’s start by showing y’all the trailers shall we? 🎥

—

Non-Spoiler Plot Overview

Eight years after becoming Santa, Scott Calvin’s got the job down… but now the “Mrs. Clause” throws a wrench in his candy-cane-perfect life. If he doesn’t get married by Christmas Eve, he’ll stop being Santa. Meanwhile, back at the North Pole, a plastic clone meant to fill in for him while he’s away develops a serious dictator complex and decides all children deserve coal.


—

Character Rundown

Scott Calvin / Santa Claus (Tim Allen) – Still sarcastic, still heartfelt, but under pressure to find a wife before Christmas Eve.

Charlie Calvin (Eric Lloyd) – Scott’s son, who’s been acting out at school and landing himself on the naughty list.

Carol Newman (Elizabeth Mitchell) – The strict school principal who slowly thaws to Scott’s charm.

Bernard (David Krumholtz) – Head Elf with a permanent “I’ve been managing this place for centuries” energy.

Curtis (Spencer Breslin) – The rules-obsessed elf whose big mouth creates half the movie’s problems.

Toy Santa (Tim Allen) – The plastic, Buzz Lightyear-sounding clone whose black-and-white morality turns the North Pole into a holiday dystopia.

The Tooth Fairy (Art LaFleur) – A hilariously bureaucratic version of the childhood legend who ends up playing rescuer.

Lucy Miller (Liliana Mumy) – Charlie’s little sister and certified reindeer chocolatier.



—

Pacing

The movie has that early 2000s Disney holiday energy — brisk, lighthearted, and full of pratfalls. The romance subplot and North Pole chaos get equal screen time, so nothing drags too long, though the plastic dictator arc sometimes feels more like a sketch than a threat.


—

Pros

Tim Allen’s double performance as Scott and Toy Santa is silly but genuinely fun.

Elizabeth Mitchell is charming and gives the film a sweet emotional center.

The Tooth Fairy subplot is absurd in all the right ways.

Feels like a cozy, rewatchable Christmas movie without taking itself too seriously.

Bernard will always be my favorite.



—

Cons

The “all kids get coal” plot is obviously doomed from the start, lowering tension.

Some humor hasn’t aged well (over-reliance on fart jokes, plastic Santa’s cartoonish villainy).

Carol and Scott’s romance moves at warp speed because of the ticking clock.



—

Final Thoughts

This is pure early-2000s Disney Christmas comfort food — cheesy, predictable, but impossible to dislike if you’re in the holiday mood. The mix of romance, magic, and a hilariously misguided clone Santa makes it a festive guilty pleasure.

Rating: 🎄 10/10 – Highly recommend, especially if you want something light and cozy. Available on Disney+.


—

Spoiler Section 🚨

Scott learns about the “Mrs. Clause” — the rule that he must be married by Christmas Eve or he’ll stop being Santa. He heads home to find a bride, leaving Curtis in charge, who decides to create a stand-in: a plastic replica of Scott. This Toy Santa starts out friendly but quickly gets hooked on the rule book, interpreting “good” and “bad” kids in the most literal way possible.

Toy Santa’s Evil Plan: He decides every child is naughty (since every kid breaks some rule) and declares that coal for everyone is the only fair solution. He militarizes the North Pole with toy soldiers, locks up Bernard, and turns the workshop into a factory of coal bricks. The elves are forbidden from questioning him, and he tries to enforce a creepy North Pole police state — candy cane striped barriers, coal assembly lines, and toy soldiers marching in formation.

Meanwhile, Scott dates Carol, the no-nonsense principal at Charlie’s school. She initially dislikes him, especially since Charlie’s been acting out, but Scott wins her over with charm, honesty, and some well-timed magic. By the time Christmas Eve arrives, Scott’s still not proposed and his Santa magic is fading.

The Tooth Fairy sneaks Scott back to the North Pole, where he and Carol (now aware of his true identity) face off against Toy Santa. In the chaos, the elves shrink Toy Santa back into a harmless plastic doll. Scott proposes to Carol in front of the entire workshop, she accepts, and he instantly regains his Santa powers. Christmas is saved, the elves celebrate, and Lucy gets a magical snow globe gift from Scott as a promise she’ll always be able to see him.