Now You See Me: Now You Don’t (2025)

“Now You See Me 3: Now You Don’t… Because I Stopped Watching” 🎩✨

Let’s start by showing y’all the trailers, shall we? 🎬

—

⚠️ Content Warning

Sustained peril, gunfire, and a dangerous overdose of “we swear this is clever” dialogue. May cause whiplash from eye-rolling too hard.


—

🎭 Non-Spoiler Plot Rundown

It’s been ten years since the Four Horsemen have been seen on stage together — and believe me, this movie will never let you forget it. Characters remind the audience every few minutes like they’re tapping us on the shoulder going, “Get it? It’s been ten years since the last one! We’re so clever!”

So, what’s the big comeback? The legendary magicians reunite to team up with a new trio of up-and-coming illusionists to expose Veronika Vanderberg (portrayed by Adele Exarchopoulos), a powerful diamond tycoon with an accent that shifts faster than a broken radio dial — Russian one minute, Italian the next, and then just… gone. She’s hoarding a heart-shaped diamond tied to shady dealings, money laundering, and, because of course, Nazis.

Their mission: steal the diamond, expose Veronika’s corruption, and prove the magic still lives. The result? Less magic, more digital hallucination. What once felt like slick misdirection now feels like Hogwarts got a heist movie.


—

👥 Character Rundown

J. Daniel Atlas (Jesse Eisenberg) – Still the smug leader, but with all the energy of someone halfway through his grocery list.

Merritt McKinney (Woody Harrelson) – Uses hypnosis twice, cracks a few jokes, mostly looks like he’s waiting for lunch.

Jack Wilder (Dave Franco) – The quick-hand thief now reduced to tossing props and playing fetch with the script.

Henley Reeves (Isla Fisher) – Back for more red-haired chaos, this time using her wedding ring as a literal plot device.

Thaddeus Bradley (Morgan Freeman) – Appears for a few minutes, mumbles gravely, dies, and probably cashes his check mid-scene.

Dylan Rhodes (Mark Ruffalo) – Supposedly locked in a Russian prison. Translation: “actor unavailable.”


The new Gen Z recruits:

Justice Smith – The “Detective Pikachu” actor plays the tech-savvy illusionist hiding way too many secrets.

Nicholas Galitzine – The curly-haired showman who causes chaos and pretends it’s activism.

Ariana Greenblatt – The escape-room prodigy who speaks fluent Gen Z slang while the older magicians look exhausted.

🎩 The Horsemen Were Never Meant to Be Heroes

One of the biggest misconceptions this franchise fell into over time is treating the Four Horsemen like protagonists. In the original film, they were never supposed to be the “good guys.” They were morally gray illusionists — antiheroes at best — using sleight of hand, manipulation, and spectacle to expose corruption while committing crimes themselves. That tension between “are they justice or chaos?” was what made the first movie work so well.

But as the series went on, the studio started misunderstanding its own premise. Instead of keeping that mystery alive, the sequels polished the Horsemen into marketable heroes — quippy, charming, and safe. The edge was gone. What started as a morally complex story about revenge, illusion, and control slowly turned into a glossy superhero ensemble with sparkly magic tricks instead of personality.

By the third film, they’re no longer magicians bending reality — they’re practically Avengers with smoke machines. The fun was watching the trick unfold. The downfall was when the trick became the entire show.

🎩 The Four Horsemen Forgot How to Be Cool

You know what made the first movie work? The Four Horsemen weren’t heroes — they were chaotic anti-heroes. They had swagger, mystery, and this smug “we’re probably breaking five laws right now” energy that made them fun to watch.

Here? They’re basically Robin Hood with a stage pass. They rob corrupt billionaires, talk about justice, and act like they’re saving the world one hologram at a time. It’s not cool — it’s corny. There’s no bite left. The danger’s gone, the thrill’s gone, and every illusion feels more like a corporate PowerPoint on morality than a magic trick.

The first movie had magicians outsmarting the system.
This one? It’s magicians playing Robin Hood!



—

⏳ Pacing / Flow

This story lurches from a convoluted auction heist to a Scooby-Doo puzzle mansion to a sand-filled deathtrap, all while screaming, “Look! Magic!” Every transition feels like another rabbit the writers pulled out of their hat without checking if it was still alive.


—

🌟 Pros

Occasionally funny — mostly by accident.

Some production design moments (the twisting hallway, puzzle-box mansion) at least look neat.

Woody Harrelson, even phoning it in, can still get a chuckle with a facial expression alone.



—

❌ Cons

Magic replaced with miracles. Every illusion is now holograms, CGI, or witchcraft.

Emotionally dead cast. The returning actors look exhausted and detached; Morgan Freeman seems mentally halfway home.

Accent chaos. The villain’s voice changes more times than the plot does.

Nazi subplot. Nobody asked. Nobody wanted. Nobody needed.

Continuity amnesia. Suddenly Thaddeus is their mentor instead of their enemy. Huh?

Third act? Logic packs its bags and moves out completely.



—

🧩 Final Thoughts

The first Now You See Me was clever misdirection. This one’s a PowerPoint on “How Not to Write a Heist.” It feels like the franchise saw Fast & Furious and said, “What if we do that, but with magic and less fun?”

My main reaction was this as well, Is this a trick? Or did they really write this? Sorry, I really wanted to love this movie. But I ended up not, i truly hope they don’t make another one.


—

⭐ Rating

4 / 10


—

⚠️ Spoiler Warning

Below here lies the rabbit hole where all logic went to die.


—

🩸 Spoilers (Full Breakdown)

The film opens with a flashy robbery at a crypto-currency den. Our new trio “summons” hologram versions of the original Horsemen, catching the attention of Atlas (Jesse Eisenberg), who gets a mysterious Eye card saying these kids matter. Cue the reunion: the OG team plus the rookies must pull off a diamond heist from Veronika Vanderberg.

The first big set piece, the auction heist, plays out like a fever dream. In a crowded, guard-filled room, Nicholas Galitzine’s character pretends to be a photographer, convinces Veronika to hold the diamond, while Justice Smith quietly flips a lever that swaps the real case for a fake one. No one notices. Then Galitzine stages a protest, tips over an ice sculpture, tosses the diamond on the floor, and Smith casually picks it up and hurls it across the crowd to Atlas. All of this happens in public. It’s less “illusion” and more “everyone here is blind.”

Later, the gang follows clues to a puzzle mansion where riddles, trapdoors, and parlor tricks await. They bicker with Gen Z slang jokes while Thaddeus Bradley (Morgan Freeman) randomly appears looking like he wants to nap. The plot thickens — or curdles — when they discover Veronika’s family ties to a Nazi illusionist, a subplot so misguided it’s almost offensive. Before anyone can process that, police burst in, somehow knowing every secret door combination, and chase them through the maze like cartoon cops.

Inside the mansion, we get a “magic montage” that’s straight-up witchcraft. Henley shreds playing cards into confetti, another character fans them around the room, and suddenly a white dress materializes onto her body mid-air. It’s not misdirection; it’s Hogwarts After Dark.

Thaddeus’s big death scene lands with the weight of a wet deck of cards. He hides behind mirrored glass, gets shot by a cop, and collapses dramatically, gasping a cliché like “Don’t waste my death.” The Horsemen mourn him like a mentor figure — the same guy who literally tried to expose and imprison them in the first movies. Apparently everyone here has collective amnesia.

Then comes the infamous sand-trap sequence. The team gets captured, dropped into a glass box filling with sand, and decide to flood it using a pipe they yank down with a belt. When that doesn’t work, Henley uses her wedding ring to chip at the glass underwater until it cracks, because apparently diamonds beat physics.

Meanwhile, Veronika is summoned to deliver the diamond to a mysterious caller in a desert bunker during a sandstorm. Surprise! The masked villain is actually Justice Smith’s character, revealed to be her secret half-brother seeking revenge for their father’s crimes. There’s no build-up, no foreshadowing — just “Hi sis, remember me?” She shoots him, he catches the bullet in his mouth, and the curtains literally rise to reveal the “bunker” is a theater stage.

How? Well, apparently, she was tricked into stepping into a fake elevator that was on a bridge, then pushed sideways across town into the stage while she thought she was descending into the bunker. She never noticed the motion, sound, or shift in gravity because “sandstorm.” Yes, this is written dialogue.

The Horsemen appear onstage, humiliate Veronika publicly, and promise to return the diamond’s money to the people. Everyone applauds. Justice Smith gives a heartfelt speech about honesty that feels like a TED Talk written by ChatGPT 2.0.

Finally, in the obligatory sequel-bait ending, the team regroups at the trio’s apartment. There’s a mildly funny gag where Woody Harrelson tries sparkling water for the first time, calls it “Gen Z poison,” then likes it. A package arrives containing the Eye puzzle from earlier. They solve it, and a hologram of Mark Ruffalo’s Dylan Rhodes appears, saying, “Surprise, I’m out of prison, and you’re all officially part of the team now.” Cue dramatic music, smug smiles, and the promise of Now You See Me 4: Maybe Don’t.


—

🧨 Why It Fails

Because none of it feels like magic anymore. The heists are CGI hallucinations, the characters sleepwalk through dialogue, and the twist could only shock someone who forgot how cause-and-effect works. The once-clever premise of illusionists outsmarting the system has become a parody of itself — one bad trick away from pulling a rabbit out of thin air and calling it character development.


—

4 / 10. The illusion is gone, the trick revealed, and the audience left clapping out of habit.