Scooby-Doo! Return to Zombie Island (2019)

From Gothic Horror Masterpiece to Soulless, Corporate Slop


—

🎬 Trailer

Let’s start with showing you the trailer, shall we?

Yeah if ur rubbed off the wrong way just by this trailer, then this film will do nothing for y’all.

—

📝 Non-Spoiler Thoughts

This movie is a betrayal. A 0/10, burn-it-from-history, never-speak-its-name-again kind of betrayal.

But to explain why it’s so awful, you’ve got to understand why the original Scooby-Doo on Zombie Island (1998) is considered a classic. That film was bold. It was the first time Scooby-Doo actually broke its own formula — the monsters weren’t just people in masks, they were REAL.

The 1998 original had:

Grotesque zombie designs – skeletal, sunken, rotting, genuinely terrifying.

A gothic atmosphere – eerie Louisiana swamps, candlelit mansions, and haunting music.

A tragic backstory – Lena and Simone’s tale of betrayal and the werecats made it chilling and unforgettable.

Nightmare fuel sequences – reanimation scenes where skeletons grew flesh and muscle in grotesque detail.

Real horror stakes – people died, souls were consumed, and for once Scooby-Doo wasn’t “safe.”


It became a gateway horror film for a whole generation. For many of us, it was the first time Scooby-Doo was genuinely scary.

Now compare that with Return to Zombie Island (2019). Instead of doubling down on what worked, it softens every edge. It retcons the original into a joke, turns terrifying zombies into laughable mascots, and strips away every ounce of atmosphere. What was once bold and daring is now bland and corporate.

This isn’t a continuation. This is an insult.

The first insult is that the movie tries to tell us that the gang are now teenagers, even though that’s a major ratcon, because in the first movie, they were adults! Ohh, andy animation has changed like drastically.If you cannot tell it’s lightly kept the designs of the scooby gang correctly from the original film. But everything else is overexaated to look cartoonish.

Scooby-Doo! Return to Zombie Island (2019) – Animation Style

By contrast, the animation in Return to Zombie Island feels like a downgrade. It abandons the moody hand-drawn look of the 1998 original and instead uses the flatter, more modern “straight-to-DVD Scooby-Doo” style — bright colors, smoother outlines, and less shadow. While it’s serviceable for a Saturday-morning cartoon vibe, it completely undercuts the creepy atmosphere that made the first film iconic. The zombies themselves look tame, with rounded features and goofy expressions, more like background goons than actual threats. This animation choice makes the film feel sanitized, more comedic than chilling, and ultimately robs it of the horror edge that defined the original.


—

👥 Characters & Voice Acting

Scooby & Shaggy: Dialed up to shrieking buffoons. Any charm is gone. Now they are this stuck up snoothie, people that try to prevent their friends from solving a case instead. Forcing them to relax on the vacation that they want. My god you guys suck.

Daphne: Reduced to a flat “TV personality.” Nothing memorable.

Velma: Stripped of her wit and insight — she may as well not be there. Now she’s get this, she’s, she’s.She’s certain that zombies don’t exist, that their previous outings on that island was just a hallucination, like what the how delusional do you have to be to think that was a delusion? Yeah, as long as I read it from the grave. Cat people burning alive?Oh, yeah, must have been a hoax. The hell?

Fred: The ultimate background extra. Barely a leader, barely even active. His only contribution to this film is that he’s having dreams of his mystery machine that he had to sell, he treats that thing like it’s a ex girlfriend. Fred my dude you have issues.


It feels like they’re all cosplaying Mystery Inc. instead of being them.


—

⏳ Pacing & Flow

It drags, then sprints. The first act is “yay vacation!” tone-deaf fluff. The “scary” sequences are neutered. And the ending? Rushed, hollow, and infuriating.

Cons 👎

A total betrayal of the original. The sequel retcons everything iconic about Zombie Island and turns it into a joke.

Watered down zombies. The terrifying, grotesque designs of the 1998 film get replaced with generic, bland, cheap-looking “monsters.” Straight downgrade.

Zero atmosphere. Gone are the eerie swamps, ghostly chills, and genuine horror. What we get is flat animation and safe Saturday morning vibes.

A plot that doesn’t care. The story isn’t just bad — it’s an active insult to the original’s boldness. It feels like it was written to erase what made the first film daring.

Comedy over horror. Instead of balancing scares and laughs, the sequel throws in lame gags that undercut any chance at tension.

Disrespect to fans. This isn’t just a weak film, it’s one that treats viewers like they can’t handle what they grew up with.

Pointless retcon. Making the original’s zombies “just costumes” completely guts the impact of one of Scooby-Doo’s best twists ever.


—

🌊 Final Thoughts

This isn’t Scooby-Doo horror. This is corporate-mandated, family-safe, flavorless slop. It doesn’t just fail as a sequel — it actively erases what made the original so powerful.

It’s one thing to be bad. But this film doesn’t even try? Oh, wait nevermind, it does try.It tries to ruin a beloved film.So this gets an Fudge You. I hate this movie with all my fiber.

⭐ Rating: 0/10


—

⚠️ Spoiler Warning ⚠️

Alright, now let’s break down why this movie should’ve been buried six feet under.


—

🧟 Spoilers & Breakdown

The Setup: The gang is “retired” from mysteries. Already dumb. They go to Moonscar Island as a vacation trip for Daphne’s birthday. Instead of dread, we get corny jokes.

Zombie Reveal: In ’98, zombies clawed out of graves with glowing eyes, skeletal faces, and grotesque reanimation sequences. In 2019, they look like Party City rejects — smooth, cartoonish, goofy. They don’t look like corpses. They look like Scooby villains in rubber suits.

The Retcon From Hell: The 1998 twist was groundbreaking because the monsters were REAL. Here? “Haha nope, it was costumes all along.” That’s not just lazy. That’s a crime. That’s like remaking Alien and saying the Xenomorph was a dude in cosplay.

Lena & Simone: Two of Scooby’s best villains, erased from existence. Their tragic, haunting backstory is gone. Instead, the island’s history is gutted and replaced with generic nonsense.

Jacques: One of the creepiest supporting characters in the original — reduced to nothing.

The Ending: Instead of horror, we get a slapstick wrap-up. The movie is terrified of its own legacy.



—

🧟 Then vs. Now: Zombie Designs

1998 Zombies: Pale, skeletal, grotesque. They looked terrifying, with lifeless glowing eyes and ghastly groans. Their reanimation scene — flesh and muscle sliding over bone — scarred kids for life in the best way.

2019 Zombies: Goofy, soft, unscary. They look like extras from a Saturday morning cartoon, not undead horrors. It’s like they Disneyfied nightmare fuel into a Halloween mascot.


This downgrade is unforgivable.


—

😡 The Angry Retcon Rant

The original Zombie Island mattered because it dared to break Scooby-Doo’s rules. Monsters were real. That’s why fans loved it.

This sequel? It erases that and says “just kidding, costumes.” It’s cowardly, soulless, and corporate. You don’t undo a beloved classic to soften it for kids who weren’t even alive when it came out. That’s not storytelling. That’s vandalism.


—

🧟 This Movie & The Zombie Genre

For many kids, Zombie Island (1998) was their gateway into zombies. It’s the reason some of us went on to love horror. It was dark, eerie, and grotesque — and it stuck with you.

Return to Zombie Island isn’t a horror movie. It’s an eraser, trying to scrub away what worked and replace it with corporate-approved bubblegum.


—

👎 Why Fans Are Furious

Zombie designs neutered and downgraded.

The retcon destroys the original’s iconic twist.

Lena & Simone’s story erased.

The tone turned into safe slapstick.

The atmosphere gutted.



—

🪦 Final Word

Scooby-Doo! Return to Zombie Island (2019) is not just bad. It’s insulting.

It downgrades terrifying zombie designs into jokes. It erases Lena & Simone. It retcons the most iconic twist in Scooby-Doo history. And it turns gothic horror into corporate oatmeal.

For fans of the 1998 masterpiece, this isn’t a sequel. It’s a funeral.